Shop Chocolates
Best Sellers
Hot Cocoa Bombs
Chocolate-Covered Oreos
Chocolate Tortues (Turtles)
Chocolate-Covered Almond Toffee
Chocolate-Covered Fairy Food
Chocolate Collection
Handcrafted Chocolates
Fruit & Nuts
Chocolate Bars & Barks
Drinking Chocolate
Bulk Chocolate
Special Occasion
Gift Cards
Birthday & Anniversary
Thinking of You & Thank you
Chocolate Gift Boxes
Gift Sets
Other Confections
Gummi, Licorice, & Taffy
Novelty Candy
About
Where to Find Us
Current Specials
Contact Us
FAQs
Flavor Guide
Other Services
Chocolate Classes
Business Gifts
Events and Weddings
Fundraising
Select Page
Peanut butter
Showing all 4 results
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Chocolate-Covered Nutter Butter® Cookies
$
3.80
Chocolate-Covered Pretzel Rods with Caramel or Peanut Butter
$
4.65
Giant Peanut Butter Cup
$
5.45
Peanut Butter Caramel Squares
$
6.00
Product categories
Filter by Category
Select all
Best Sellers
Bulk Chocolate
Chocolate Bars & Barks
Chocolate Gift Boxes
Drinking Chocolate
Fruit & Nuts
Gummi, Licorice, & Taffy
Handcrafted Chocolates
Occasion
Seasonal
Novelty Candy
Gift Sets
Product tags
Filter by Type
Allergy-friendly
Baking & pantry
Caramel
Cookies
DIY
Fruit
Gluten-free
Kids
Kids at heart
Lunch box
Mint
nut-free
Nuts
Peanut butter
Pretzel
Soy-free
Sugar-Free
Filter
Clear
goodnatured
